Tuesday, February 5, 2013

It’s 2013 and Brooklyn GOP Chairman Craig Eaton has shown very little interest in fielding a full slate of strong Republican candidates for this year’s City-wide, County-wide and Council District elections


Except for a few GUYS  “running” for mayor, and the even fewer talking about or thinking about running for City Council, Brooklyn Republicans haven’t been introduced to anybody who might be running on a GOP slate this year  —   of course, County Leader Craig Eaton probably prefers to have flexibility to make last minute Wilson-Pakula deals with certain Brooklyn Democrats.  But people need to ask  —  Mr. Eaton, what have you and your fellow NYC Republican County Chairmen accomplished with all your nonsensical meetings with/about prospective GOP mayoral candidates ?  Mr. Eaton, where are the Republican candidates in your Brooklyn  Republican Party Renaissance ?  Mr. Eaton, what kind of Republican Party are you running in Brooklyn ?


In the old days, ambitious candidates for an upcoming municipal election year made their rounds of the Republican Clubs’ and the County Organization’s Holiday parties  —   Cue Tony Bennet: “... Where did it go ? ... That was ‘Once upon a Time’ so very long ago ...”  This year there were a few mayoral candidates  —  that’s it.

There is a report (with video) that the five NYC GOP County Leaders had met (yet again, this time in Manhattan) at the Metropolitan Republican Club to speak to candidates and to see if they could “finally” settle upon a body with a name to run as their consensus Republican candidate for Mayor of the City of New York. Yet again, these five GUYS accomplished nothing, except putting on an “Evening at Improv” performance of  five clueless guys trying to convince somebody that they are okay with a GOP mayoral  primary this year ( See “Who's Going To Be The GOP's 2013 Nominee For Mayor Of NYC? Let's Go To The Videotape ” by Celeste Katz, 2-4-13, Daily Politics/Daily News [http://www.nydailynews.com/blogs/node/135603 ]; next Eaton and the others plan to do a skit of five guys coming home and trying to explain to their significant others how their doctors just told them that a confirming medical diagnosis of their having a case of the wet-drippy-clap isn’t as bad as it sounds).

One of the things that they struck-out on was convincing any of the second-tier candidates for mayor (clearly, some of them are not top-shelf mayor material ) to accept lower spots on the city-wide GOP ticket. So far our computer searches and personal investigations have determined that there has been no expression of interest whatsoever in the GOP lines for Public Advocate or NYC Controller, either by the nominal mayoral candidates or anybody else.

At this stage, the Brooklyn county-wide races are even more problematic than the city-wides.  The Borough President line is always a problem slot in the Brooklyn GOP lineup. As usual, Eaton will probably name one of his loyal retainers as he did in 2009, when it was Marc L. D’Ottavio’s turn to take one for the team. The District Attorney slot presents a different, but far more interesting problem.

Since 1997 the Brooklyn GOP’s DA line has been “filled” by giving a Wilson-Pakula to the incumbent DA, Charles “Joe” Hynes, a Democrat, and filing sufficient Republican signatures on his behalf (in 1993 DA Hynes had been given a Wilson-Pakula for the Republican line and he had also filed sufficient signatures, but he agreed to the removal of his name from the Republican ballot along with the name of another GOP candidate-petitioner for DA; the GOP DA slot in 1993 was then filled by  the other candidate who “won” an opportunity to ballot write-in primary).  Except for 2005, a year when the machinations leading up to giving the Wilson-Pakula for the GOP line to Hynes have been hotly disputed, the GOP does not appear to have obtained any patronage or other apparent consideration for its giving the incumbent DA unchallenged access to the Republican line. That includes 2005 when the GOP line was very important to DA Hynes; it would have become especially important if he had lost in the tight Democratic Primary for that year.

So far, the only candidates that have announced for DA are the three Democrats running for that position on the Democratic Party ( and probably other lines):  the incumbent DA, Charles Hynes, is a former Marine, who has a reputation as a tough law and order kind of guy, and at this time and of these three, probably the only candidate worthy of consideration for the GOP Wilson-Pakula; Abe George, a former Manhattan prosecutor, is a social liberal with significant support from a top-shelf  Democrat lawyer David Boies; and Kenneth Thompson, a man with lots of national and international connections, and a very flashy resume. Rock Hackshaw, posting on Room Eight says that he supports the former Manhattan ADA, Abe George, but if it winds up that the two minority candidates continue in the race against the incumbent, the three-way would favor DA Hynes (See “Road to City Hall (Part Two)” by Rock Hackshaw, 2-4-13, Room Eight [http://www.r8ny.com/blog/rock_hackshaw/the_road_to_city_hall_part_two.html]). A very interesting comment points out that candidate Kenneth Thompson co-authored a “Whitewash” report of the government’s deadly assault on the “Branch Davidian” compound in Waco (See Comment, “I'll take Abe over Ken for Brooklyn D.A.” by Vincenzo, 2-5-13, Room Eight [same link as Hackshaw]; since a GOP congressional committee criticized the “internal Waco reports” by the ATF and FBI, and reached opposite conclusions, I’ll be researching the available sources on these subjects for a future analysis of the Hynes-George-Thompson DA candidacies  — unless of course, if the Brooklyn GOP actually fields its own DA candidate, which would render the exercise moot).

As for Republican City Council candidates in Brooklyn districts, only three names have made it “into the public arena”   —  actually that’s “into the public media”: Hardhat Andrew Sullivan, a 9-11 mosque opponent,  blogger and video journalist; John Quaglione, State Senator Martin Golden’s Vice Chief of Staff and neighborhood activist; and David Storobin, the former State Senator.

It’s a good thing that it’s starting to look like a  “September Primary” for all of these offices.  Eaton obviously needs the time to get his act together, before he goes to the district leaders and yells at them to get their acts together.

5 comments:

Galewyn Massey said...

UPDATE: The Republican County Leaders not supporting Joseph Lhota might already be too late getting on board that train and are trying to figure out some kind of "Stop Lhota" strategy.

The "new " Bay Ridge Conservative Club is hosting Mr. Lhota as a "Special Guest" at its President's Day Dinner honoring the C-Party State Chairman Mike Long. If anybody thinks that club President Liam McCabe and Dinner Chairwoman Christine Sisto publicly invited Mayoral Candidate Joseph Lhota to the event on their own toot, they don't know how the Conservative Party works.

Once more, it looks like the very active Conservative Party Tail might well be wagging the moody old Republican Party dog; and for the umpteenth time, the Brooklyn Conservative Party is on its way to out-maneuvering the Brooklyn GOP.

Anonymous said...

Hynes is a tough law and order guy? Maybe some Republicans from Breezy Point think so.

Galewyn Massey said...

Old news ! Give it a rest !

DA Hynes' residence had been raised in a long ago election litigation and then it was abandoned after the Court heard from the pastor of St. Patrick's in Bay Ridge. I've seen Hynes coming out of his apartment on the corner of O__ ___ and M__ ___ myself,

Btw, a lot of those "Republicans" in Breezy also still have year-round homes in Brooklyn that are in no way shams. I know at least one of them is a GOP district leader.

Galewyn Massey said...

UPDATE: Eaton on Eaton (and the rest of the NYC GOP County Chairmen) — “Despite months of candidate sitdowns and private confabs, ‘We can't combine any of these candidates into a ticket, so it seems like a primary is going to be inevitable,’ Brooklyn GOP Chairman Craig Eaton told the Daily News Tuesday. *** If it has to happen, Eaton said, the party can only urge the contestants to heed former President Ronald Reagan’s ‘Eleventh Commandment’ nixing the trashing of fellow Republicans. *** ‘We want to try and make it a very civil, professional primary so that we're not giving any more ammunition to the Democrats,’ he said.” (“NYC's Looming GOP Mayoral Primary: Is It A Free Country, Or Just A Free-For-All?” by Celeste Katz, 1/6/13, Daily Politics/Daily News [http://www.nydailynews.com/blogs/dailypolitics/2013/02/nycs-looming-gop-mayoral-primary-is-it-a-free-country-or-just-a-free-for-all-0]

I can just picture Craig Eaton looking at the videos of all that and emphatically saying to himself in his Eaton-like way, " PATHETIC ! "

This is all excellent news for independent Republicans in Brooklyn, some of whom already had been gearing up for the 2013 primaries.

bixsco12 said...

"Since 1997 the Brooklyn GOP’s DA line has been “filled” by giving a Wilson-Pakula to the incumbent DA, Charles “Joe” Hynes, a Democrat, and filing sufficient Republican signatures on his behalf (in 1993 DA Hynes had been given a Wilson-Pakula for the Republican line and he had also filed sufficient signatures, but he agreed to the removal of his name from the Republican ballot along with the name of another GOP candidate-petitioner for DA; the GOP DA slot in 1993 was then filled by the other candidate who “won” an opportunity to ballot write-in primary). "

You are incorrect about this. Check the ballot from 2001- they had a republican candidate.